Not catastrophically wrong, usually. Wrong in the quiet way that doesn't announce itself: a figure roughly 30% too high, a conversion action counting a step that's not a sale, or an upload that stopped in March and went unnoticed because the number on the screen kept moving.

This matters more than it used to. Manual bidding tolerated bad data because a human was making the decisions. Smart Bidding doesn't tolerate it at all. It's extremely good at chasing whatever you point it at, which is precisely the problem when what you've pointed it at is wrong. Optimising towards a broken conversion just makes you worse, faster.

Here are the six checks I run on a new account, in the order I run them. They take an afternoon.

1. Does the platform number match the business number?

Start here, because it catches the largest errors fastest. Take last month's conversions in Google Ads and compare them against what your order system, CRM or finance report says actually happened.

They won't match exactly, and they're not supposed to. Google attributes on click date rather than order date, and it counts conversions it believes it influenced. But you're not looking for a match. You're looking for an explainable gap. If Google says 400 and your back office says 250, and nobody can account for the difference, stop and find out why before touching anything else.

2. Is anything being counted twice?

The most common single fault. It happens when a conversion is tracked through more than one route: a Google Ads tag and a GA4 import of the same event, or a tag firing on a page that can be reloaded or reached twice.

In Google Ads, open Goals and look at every conversion action, not just the primary ones. Two actions with suspiciously similar volumes, one from a website tag and one imported from Analytics, is the classic signature. Check the "Count" setting too: lead generation should almost always be set to one per click, not every. Set to every, a single enquirer refreshing a thank-you page becomes three leads.

A number that's 30% too high is more dangerous than one that's missing. Missing data looks broken. Inflated data looks like success.

3. Are the values real?

For ecommerce, check that conversion values are actual order values rather than a placeholder somebody set during launch and never revisited. I've found accounts optimising against a flat value per sale on a catalogue where products range from £8 to £400.

Also decide what value you actually want the bidding to chase. Revenue is the default and it's not always right. If your margins vary a lot by product, bidding on revenue quietly pushes budget towards your least profitable lines, because they're often the cheapest to sell.

4. Has an offline import stopped?

If you upload offline conversions from a CRM, check when the last successful upload actually ran. Not whether the integration exists. When it last ran.

Offline imports fail silently more often than anything else in the stack. A token expires, a field name changes, someone rotates a key, and the upload stops. The account carries on bidding against whatever data it last received, and because there's still a number moving on the screen, nobody notices for months. This is worth a diary reminder rather than a one-off check.

5. Do the primary and secondary actions make sense?

Google lets you mark conversion actions as primary, which bidding optimises towards, or secondary, which are observed only. This distinction is frequently a mess.

Newsletter signups, PDF downloads and "contact page viewed" set as primary will drag Smart Bidding towards the cheapest and least valuable outcomes in your account. Open the list and ask of each one: do I want to buy more of this specific thing at the expense of the others? If not, it's secondary.

6. Is enhanced conversions actually working?

Enhanced conversions improves measurement by matching hashed first-party data. Half the accounts I see have it switched on in the interface and not properly implemented on the site, which produces a diagnostic warning nobody reads and no benefit.

Check the status in the conversion action's settings rather than assuming the toggle is the whole story. If it says needs attention, it's not working.

What to do when you find something

Two things worth knowing before you start fixing.

First, changing conversion tracking resets what the bidding has learned. Expect a fortnight of unstable performance afterwards, and don't judge the account during it. That's a reason to fix everything in one deliberate go rather than dribbling changes out over a month.

Second, your historical reporting becomes a mixture of two measurement regimes. Note the date you changed it somewhere permanent, because in six months somebody will compare across that boundary and reach a confident, wrong conclusion.

None of this is difficult work. It's just nobody's favourite job, which is exactly why it's where the money is.

Written by Michael Veal, a freelance PPC consultant based in Edinburgh.
Something in here apply to your account? Get in touch, or read more in the blog.